Injuries by Year and Run

2020–2025; closer lines indicate more consistent extraction

Comparing total injuries at each severity level across both test runs to check for consistency. Divergence between the two lines suggests the extraction is producing different results for the same articles.


Injuries by Immediate Cause

2020–2025


Objective Risk Factors

2020–2025


Subjective Risk Factors

2020–2025


Social Risk Factors

2020–2025


State Agreement

2020–2025; top 20 states by combined article count


Injuries by YDS Grade

2020–2025


Agreement by Data Type

Each point = one value; line = median. Higher is more consistent.

Distribution of Jaccard % agreement scores across all values within each data category. Each point is one factor, state, or grade. The vertical line shows the median for that category.


Fatal Injury Discrepancies

Climbers tagged as a fatal injury in one run but not the other. Each row represents a case where the two runs disagreed on whether someone died.


Analysis by Nate Downer

Data from https://publications.americanalpineclub.org/